February 6, 2025

Total Body Cleanse Debate: What Works, What’s Dangerous, and What’s Just Marketing

Listen on: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Amazon Music | Podcast Index | Overcast | YouTube

Total body cleanses (detox) promise renewed energy, sharper focus, and a “clean” body, but the science often tells a different story. From juice fasts to sauna sweats, let’s dive into the research to uncover what’s hype and what’s helpful.

The Allure of Detoxing: Why It Appeals

The detox industry flourishes by targeting our concerns about toxins in the environment, often highlighting:

  1. Environmental Toxins: Heavy metals like mercury and lead, microplastics, and pesticides are frequently cited as harmful agents that require “flushing out.”
  2. Body Imbalances: Claims of inflammation, chronic fatigue, and microbiome dysregulation are used to justify detox solutions.
  3. Western Medicine Gaps: People with unresolved chronic symptoms may turn to detoxes when conventional medicine fails to provide answers.

But how much of this is marketing versus science.

Detox Methods: What They Involve

Most detoxes revolve around three main principles:

  1. Eliminating “Bad Stuff”: Juice fasts, water-only diets, or severe calorie restrictions are marketed as ways to minimize toxin intake.
  2. Adding “Good Stuff”: Supplements and foods like coriander, citric acid, or special teas are touted to bind toxins.
  3. Flushing Toxins: Techniques such as saunas, diuretics, laxatives, and even colon cleanses claim to remove waste.

The idea is compelling, but are these methods supported by evidence?

The Science Behind Detoxing

The body already has a robust detoxification system: the liver and kidneys. Here’s how the science stacks up against detox claims:

  • Known Toxin Overloads: Rare conditions like lead poisoning or iron overload are treated with specific medical interventions, such as chelation therapy. For example, chelation agents can bind heavy metals for safe removal from the body​.
  • Animal Studies: Coriander and citric acid reduced cadmium in fish and lead in mice, but these effects haven’t been replicated in humans (source)​. And, we are not fish (or mice)..
  • Human Studies: A systematic review concluded that detox cleanses lack credible evidence of benefit for humans. No rigorous, randomized controlled trials (RCTs) showed improvements in markers like blood toxicity or overall health (source)​. Contrarily, a rare RCT on a detox supplement containing papaya, peppermint, fenugreek, and ginger showed no difference in GI symptoms, blood markers, or body composition compared to a placebo (source)​.
  • Sweating and Sauna Use: While sweat contains trace amounts of toxins, systematic reviews found the quantities too small to meaningfully detoxify the body. Methods used in studies, such as scraping sweat off skin, also led to contaminated results (source)​.

Why Detox Feels Like It Works

Despite the lack of evidence, people may report feeling better after a detox. Here’s potentially why:

  1. Placebo Effect: Believing a cleanse will help can lead to a perceived improvement in well-being.
  2. Temporary Weight Loss: Reduced caloric intake and water loss may allow us to feel “skinny” for a short period of time…
  3. Agency: Taking proactive steps, even symbolic ones, can boost morale and a sense of control over health

Risks of Detoxing

While short-term detoxes may be safe for healthy individuals, prolonged use carries risks:

  • Nutritional Deficiencies: Extended fasting can lead to deficits in protein, vitamins, and minerals.
  • Electrolyte Imbalances: Excessive use of diuretics or laxatives may disrupt hydration and electrolyte levels.
  • Underlying Conditions: Those with diabetes or kidney disease may face complications if detoxing without medical supervision (source)​.

The detox supplement market also remains poorly regulated, increasing the risk of harmful additives or inaccurate labeling.

For those curious about personal experimentation, an “N of 1” trial—where you measure your baseline, test a new intervention, and reassess—is a scientific way to determine what works for your body. Consult with your doctor before starting any new protocol.

Final Thoughts

The detox industry may sell hope, but the evidence doesn’t back its claims. Your liver and kidneys are already working hard to keep you healthy. Instead of chasing quick fixes, invest in sustainable habits for long-term wellness.

Have questions or want me to explore other topics? Let me know—I’m here to guide your journey toward living long and well.

Scientific research underscores the intricate interplay between lifestyle factors and human health. Exercise, a cornerstone of well-being, enhances cardiovascular health, boosts mood, and promotes cognitive function. Coupled with proper nutrition, it fosters optimal physical performance and supports immune function. Beyond the individual, social ties exert profound effects on health, buffering against stress and enhancing longevity. Meanwhile, exposure to hot and cold environments elicits physiological adaptations, bolstering resilience and metabolic efficiency. Adequate sleep, essential for cognitive consolidation and metabolic regulation, underscores the importance of restorative rest. Moreover, the mind-body harmony underscores the intricate relationship between mental and physical health, highlighting the profound impact of mindfulness and stress management on overall well-being. Integrating these factors into daily life cultivates a holistic approach to health promotion and disease prevention.




UNCOVER A HEALTHIER YOU

Begin your journey to improved health with my e-book,
"How to Live Long &Well."

AVAILABLE  ON

TUNE IN NOW

CHECK OUT THE PODCAST